While you may not feel sympathy for the devil, you might feel some pity for the poor soul manipulated into becoming Lucifer’s human vessel. Dean proves to be harder to manipulate as both demons and angels continue to pursue him for their own agendas. But really, it is Sam who wins the sympathy card of the night, as he falls flat on his face with the realization of what he has broken: the last seal and his brother’s trust.
Supernatural Season 5, Episode 1. Air Date: September 10, 2009

Click here to listen (right-click to download)